How Does Allergy Begin?
how does allergy begin?
A mast cell, magnified about 10,000 times. The black granules contain histamine.
`At the beginning, I thought I just had a cold. I kept sneezing and coughing, and my nose was dripping. It got better at the weekend, and I thought — that’s good, it’s gone — but then on the Monday evening it started up again. The next thing I knew, I kept getting breathless. I’d been at the sawmill a month when it began. We were cutting planks of red cedar all day, and the dust was bad, it’s true. But I didn’t know that sawdust could cause you allergies. We were given dust masks, but they made you too hot. No one wore them. I found out later, from the doctor, that some men could work years at it before they got allergic to the dust, but with me it was just a month.’
Like many people with work-related allergy, Dan can actually pinpoint the time he became sensitised – when he began making IgE antibodies against the red cedar dust allergen. For allergies that are not caused by workplace allergens, this is rarely possible. The moment when symptoms begin may be obvious, but that is often long after sensitisation (making IgE to the allergen) first occurred. Long-term studies of children show that they may start giving positive skin-prick tests to pollens (a sign that they are making IgE to those pollens) while they are toddlers, but not develop hayfever until ten years later.
The basics of immunity
The immune system defends the body against infections and cancerous cells. One of its key jobs, before going on the offensive, is to recognise the difference between:
• self and non-self (e.g. the cells lining the lung, and bacteria trying to infect the lung)
• safe-non-self (e.g. a sandwich) and dangerous-non-self (e.g. Salmonella bacteria in the sandwich).
Through mis-regulation the immune system can cause:
• allergies (perceiving safe-non-self, such as pollen, as dangerous-non-self)
• autoimmune diseases (perceiving self as non-self).
The immune system consists of dozens of different kinds of cells (the immune cells) and a number of different antibodies – specialised ‘guided missiles’ (see box on p. 15) which are produced by certain immune cells.
There is also a huge array of messenger chemicals, which send general instructions (e.g. ‘calm down!’, ‘go for it!’ or’exterminate!’) from one type of cell to another.
Immune cells are self-contained units, many of them mobile and dispersed throughout the body. They travel around in the blood, and can move out of the blood vessels and into the surrounding tissues (skin, lung, nose, etc.).
These different components – immune cells, antibodies and messenger chemicals – interact in very complex ways. When an immune reaction occurs – i.e. the immune system recognises something, or mounts an attack on something – numerous different players are involved. All the reactions described in this book are very simplified versions of what actually happens.
Research shows that the first two years of life is the most vulnerable time as regards sensitisation to allergens. Very often, sensitisation occurs in the first few months, and sometimes even before birth.
Why is a young infant so easily sensitised? The answer lies not with the baby, but with the pregnant mother-to-be, whose immune system has to overrule its natural inclination to attack anything that is non-self. Potentially, a woman’s immune system could reject a foetus in just the same way that heart transplants are rejected. To prevent attacks on the foetus, the immune system is re-tuned during pregnancy, with one aspect of immunity – the part that’s most keen to attack a foreign body – being damped down.
This aspect of immunity is coordinated by cells known as T-helper-1 cells, or Th1 cells for short. To protect the foetus, these Th1 cells are asked to ease up during pregnancy. Meanwhile, since immune protection is still needed, their colleagues, called T-helper-2 cells or Th2 cells, become more active.
The classical allergic diseases
These four pages are concerned only with the classical allergic diseases, that is:
hayfever (an allergy to pollen)
perennial allergic rhinitis (a nasal allergy to a year-round allergen such as house-dust mite)
asthma where this includes an allergic reaction atopic eczema (42)
urticaria (nettle rash or hives) where this is allergic in origin, and the accompanying angioedema (swelling due to fluid escaping from tiny blood vessels into the surrounding area; it is sometimes called ‘water retention’)
anaphylaxis (a violent allergic reaction to food, insect stings, penicillin, latex, etc.)
food allergy (in most cases, an immediate and marked reaction to food, with symptoms in the mouth; there may also be anaphylaxis).
Running the immune system
T-helper cells are, in a way, mis-named, because they do not help at all – they just give orders.
These are the supervisors of the immune reactions, telling other immune cells either to lie low or to get busy. Where Th1 and Th2 cells differ is in the types of immune cells they send into action. Among those who get their go-ahead from Th1 cells are immune cells that attack directly, without producing antibodies – these are the ones that reject transplants and could, if given free rein, reject a foetus or retard its growth.
The Th2 cells, on the other hand, have among their preferred troops the immune cells that produce IgE antibodies – the allergy-causing antibodies. So one effect of protecting the foetus from rejection is to push the immune system towards a greater tendency to allergy.
This shift of emphasis occurs in the mother’s immune system, but it carries over into the immune system of the foetus because they are sharing the same blood supply, and the blood contains the messenger substances which fine-tune the immune system. Immediately after birth, the baby’s immune system is still following the same pattern, continuing to upregulate Th2 cells and downregulate Th1 cells. This is a crucial factor in setting the stage for allergic sensitisation.
Ideally, the world that the baby encounters just after birth should nudge the immune system in the opposite direction and get it operating in a non-allergic way. But the world in which we live is far from ideal in this regard.
For one thing, it is much too clean. As far as the immune system is concerned, ‘ideal’ would mean encountering quite a bit of dirt, such as garden soil, in the early stages of life. The soil contains harmless bacteria which do not cause any symptoms, but do tweak the immune system towards Th1 cells and away from Th2 cells. Bacterial products in household dust may do the same thing (21).
A long period of consuming nothing but breast milk would also suit the baby’s immune system rather better than being fed on cow’s milk formula or being suddenly weaned onto a number of highly allergenic foods, such as egg, wheat, soya (ubiquitous in The basic cause of classical allergy is an immune reaction involving mast cells and IgE antibodies.
Mast cells are plentiful in the lining of the nose, the airways, and the digestive tract. They have counterparts in the blood, called basophils.
Seen under the microscope, both mast cells and basophils look very granular inside. The granules are tiny storage compartments, containing stockpiles of messenger chemicals, notably histamine.
Histamine causes several different reactions:
• contraction of muscle around the airways. This reduces the diameter of the airway, producing an asthma attack.
• widening of blood vessels
• increased leakiness of the smallest blood vessels, allowing fluid and immune cells to escape into the surrounding area – for example, the skin or airway lining
• as a result of these two above effects, local swelling (called oedema or angioedema) and irritation – in the skin this is experienced as urticaria, or nettle rash, in the nose it causes blockage, itching and sneezing
• if sufficient histamine is released into the blood, a drastic fall in blood pressure, due to widespread opening of blood vessels, and leakage of fluid into the tissues; this occurs in anaphylaxis (58).
Histamine is released when mast cells are activated, a process called degranulation because the cells discharge their storage granules.
Mast cells release other substances at the same time, some of which attract more immune cells to the area, causing more inflammation. They help to produce a ‘Late Phase Reaction’ which occurs after the initial allergic reaction has died down, and lasts about 24 hours (13). Once activated, mast cells also start making messenger chemicals called leukotrienes which are highly inflammatory.
What causes a mast cell to degranulate? The answer is found on the surface of the cells, where the allergy antibody, IgE, sits. One end of the IgE molecule is bound to the mast cell, and the other end can bind to the allergen concerned. In someone allergic to egg, for example, egg allergen will bind, with great specificity, to egg-specific IgE antibody.
For the receptors to pass a message to the mast cell there have to be two IgE antibodies specific for the same allergen on the mast cell – and the allergen has to bind to both these IgE molecules, cross-linking them. This is the ‘go’ signal for the mast cell to degranulate.
processed foods), fish or peanuts, before it can handle them. Not taking antibiotics before two years of age would also help (although it might, of course, be very bad for the baby in other ways). Exactly why is not yet fully understood .
An ideal world for the immune system would also lack the by-products of cigarette smoking, whether in the blood of a pregnant woman or in the air that a baby breathes – both seem to promote the allergic tendency. In addition, the perfect world would lack central heating, fitted carpets, draught-proofing and thick upholstery. A house like this is heaven for house-dust mites but not for innocent young immune systems.
The problem with house-dust mites – apart from the fact that they breed like wildfire, and hole-up in mattresses, armchairs and soft toys – is that they produce a highly allergenic protein in their droppings. This protein interferes with the membranes of cells, making them less stable. It irritates various immune cells, including mast cells (see box at left), and can even make mast cells degranulate, as if there were a true allergic reaction happening.
Once mast cells have done this, they release messenger substances that arouse the immune system and make a genuine allergic reaction –beginning with the production of IgE to the dust-mite allergen – much more likely. In other words, dust-mite allergen is an agent provocateur, an aggressive substance that actually provokes the immune system into reacting allergically.
Until recently it was widely assumed that allergens were just inoffensive, passive substances which the immune system happened to take objection to, in a distinctly unreasonable way. The new discoveries about dust-mite allergen raise the question: could other allergens be more aggressive than previously thought? Certainly the peanut allergen, or other substances found in peanuts, seems to destabilise cell membranes, which may explain why this allergen so easily sensitises young children.
The role of genes
Faced with this non-ideal world, many children pull through without developing allergies, but others do not. This is where genes come in, making one child more susceptible to our allergy-promoting lifestyle and another child less so. Exactly how the genes make this difference is still not fully understood, but there are at least twenty genes involved , and it is clearly going to be a complex story. The overall effect of these genes is a greater tendency to make IgE, combined with mast cells and basophils that are distinctly trigger-happy –much more eager to degranulate than in healthy individuals.
Given all the mayhem caused by mast cells and IgE, why does the body produce them at all? They cause a lot of damage to allergy sufferers and do little apparent good, at least for people in the Western world. The value of the mast-cell-IgE-reaction, for most of us, is historical – it wages war against large-bodied parasites such as tapeworms and schistosomes. (They are large by comparison with bacteria and viruses, and not easily tackled by other immune cells.) These unpleasant invaders have largely been eliminated in the developed world but are still rife in other countries. For millions of years such parasites were an inevitable part of human life, and this bit of our evolutionary past survives in our immune system.
The complexity of allergic reactions
`Each time the pollen season came around. I would start to get these pains, especially in my knees. I asked my doctor about it but she just looked at me rather oddly and said “take a paracetamol”. I couldn’t be sure it was linked to my hayfever, but the pains always came on just after the sneezing started. One year, it was all worse than usual, and I felt very tired too. My face was all puffy and I could feel that something was seriously amiss. That, as I now know, was because my kidneys were being affected. It was years before the doctor would refer me to an allergist, and I actually got an explanation for all this. I think for a long time my doctor thought I was making it up, or just imagining the pain in my knees.’
Karen suffers from a rare complication of hayfever involving an overload of pollen antigens and antibodies in the blood. Very large numbers of both are involved, and are bound to each other in dense tangled masses called immune complexes. Because these are carried around in the blood they are known as circulating immune complexes. They may be too large to be cleared quickly by the normal junk-munching systems that keep the blood clean.
Like a river choked with fallen leaves, which deposits some of the debris on its banks as it flows past, the blood inevitably
The other antibodies
Other than IgE, four main types of antibody exist – IgA, IgD, IgG and IgM. Although some of these antibodies help fight bacterial and viral diseases, they lack IgE’s ability to tackle certain large parasites. These other antibodies do not generally bind to mast cells, and therefore do not cause IgEstyle allergy. But they can be involved in various other sensitivity reactions – it is IgG antibodies that are active in coeliac disease for example, and IgA in dermatitis herpetiformis. And any kind of antibody can participate in circulating immune complexes, causing multiple symptoms (see below).
leaves behind some of the circulating immune complexes. They mostly become deposited in the tiny blood vessels called capillaries, particularly those in the skin, the kidneys and the joints. Inflammation (140) here can cause a range of symptoms.
This problem is known to doctors either as serum sickness or as Type III hypersensitivity. It is a well-known feature of several infections and of some autoimmune diseases.
Unfortunately, the potential for Type III hypersensitivity in allergies such as hayfever is much less well known among doctors, as Karen discovered. As well as affecting hayfever sufferers, Type III hypersensitivity can also be a complication of reactions to penicillin and certain other allergic reactions, such as insect-sting allergy.
When a reaction occurs to snake anti-venom – and it only occurs in an individual who has received snake anti-venom before – this too is Type III hypersensitivity. The snake anti-venom is cultured in horses, and the snake-bitten human who has received the snake anti-venom previously mounts a massive immune reaction to the horse proteins when snake anti-venom is injected for a second time. Large and numerous circulating immune complexes are formed, and although IgE is not involved, a very severe anaphylactoid reaction (see box on p. 59) follows.
Circulating immune complexes do not affect most allergy sufferers. But there are other immune responses that follow on from the initial allergic response in everyone with allergies –they are generally summed up as the ‘Late Phase Reaction’. This reaction starts 4-12 hours after the exposure to the allergen, and lasts about a day. It involves a number of different immune cells (including eosinophils – p. 19) and an even more varied array of messenger chemicals, making everything very complicated for medical researchers to investigate. When allergic symptoms become entrenched and difficult to treat, the Late Phase Reaction is usually implicated. But it has not been given much attention by doctors until recently, because the details are so complex and so poorly understood.